In the UK, prostitution is not illegal. However, related activities are banned: managing a brothel, kerb crawling, and soliciting in a public place are illegal. Meanwhile in Holland Prostitution is entirely legal, allowing both legislation and organisation of prostitutes which helps to avoid exploitation and abuse. Conversely the USA and much of Scandinavia outlaw prostitution and prostitutes completely.
There are 80 thousand prostitutes in the UK, and when the Metropolitan Police raided 75 brothels in Soho they found that the prostitutes earn £350 a day and the brothels had a combined turnover of £1million. In London there are an average of 28 brothels per borough and the average age for a woman to enter prostitution is 15. Unfortunately most under 18 prostitutes work on the street, which is estimated to be 10 times more dangerous than working from a house or a flat. Also concerning is that there are also up to 5,000 children involved in prostitution at any one time.
The fact that 71% of men who use prostitutes feel some kind of shame at paying for sex suggests that despite how wide spread it is paying for sex, is still considered shameful (this may reflect male impotency). But the bottom line here is that this feeling of shame is transferred on to the prostitutes themselves, they too are made to live with feelings of inadequacy. This stigma is attached by society to the prostitutes, leading to more hate and condemnation.
As for why women enter prostitution Most identify the need to pay household expenses and support their children as their primary reason, suggesting that like many unpleasant jobs prostitution is done out of necessity.
More than half the women in prostitution have been raped or sexually assaulted, so prostitution seems to be a dangerous and violating profession to be in. Furthermore, considering that 57% of women who are prostitutes were abused as children, and 70% were in care, it is easy to understand the common argument of why prostitution should be illegal, namely that prostitutes are damaged people and prostitution is just continuing their abuse. In fact some women who work as prostitutes display symptoms akin to PTSD. This all suggests that prostitution should be illegal, because it is detrimental to prostitutes mental health, not to mention the STIs that are often contracted from it.
Women are also trafficked from other countries to work in the sex industry, 60% of inner city prostitutes are immigrants. Some come to the UK intending to be prostitutes however others can be lured to the UK with the promise of stable jobs and good pay only to be smuggled through the border and forced to work in brothels. Once here the women can be controlled, just as any prostitute, by their pimp, often not paid enough for their work and unable to go to the police because of the illegality of the profession. This illustrates that unregulated prostitution leads to a mass exploitation.
Due to prostitution being unregulated by an official body, because many actions to do with it are illegal, it can often be used to make money to buy drugs. It is an easy way to make money, and part of the shady underworld, 87% of women who work in street based prostitution are Heroin users, many developing the habit and then resorting to prostitution to make money, and others becoming prostitutes and using heroin to dull their senses. These are vulnerable people who need help, however this evidence suggests neither a ban nor legalisation. Banning prostitution would potentially drive this behaviour further underground, whereas legalising it would allow the government to help prostitutes – and possibly even allow the formation of a union to protect prostitutes.
Forming a prostitutes union seems ridiculous because Prostitution is not considered a respectable career, people will not accept it as a choice, but rather assume that women who have no other option will enter prostitution – because people with another option would rather not sell sex. However there are many other professions, which aren’t exactly respectable, and they aren’t illegal. People working as porn actors for example. It isn’t really the prostitution that is disrespected, but rather the sexual desire (which is an issue old as time).
The legalisation of Prostitution reduces women’s risk of rape, theft, exploitation or violence because it would be a regulated, and prostitutes would be seen as workers, rather than illegal products to buy. Women would earn appropriate wages from their work, and it wouldn’t be an entirely unrespectable career. It would reduce trafficking because women would be in a legal career, so the illegal aspects (close links to the black market, illegal immigrants being forced to work as prostitutes) would be diminished. All this would limit the negative mental effects, such as the PTSD symptoms, and would lead to it being a healthier job.
Money is also a huge reason for prostitution to be legalised, if it was legal it could be taxed. In just 75 brothels there was a turnover of £1million. Women who work as prostitutes do not have to rely on benefits, they are being independent this would add legitimacy to their money and profession, for many of them would be impoverished without this source of income. By making prostitution legal these women will have a safer environment in which to work. There are also huge costs incurred in controlling prostitution, in the USA it is roughly $2,000 per prostitute arrested. By legalising prostitution we would be able to regulate it and make it safer, but also taxes would be made from prostitution, instead of having to police and arrest prostitutes we could protect them. This is shown in Holland where the industry is regulated under normal labour law, reducing exploitation, and the government takes 33% tax on prostitutes earnings. Zurich has illustrated one of the most inventive systems to deal with legalised prostitution, and introduced “sex drive-ins” which have alarm buttons and guards to keep prostitutes safe, they can get health check ups and support from social services on site as well. This illustrates how much easier it is to police a legal trade, and how much more protection can be provided for prostitutes.
Prostitution provides sex for both male and female clients, which is good for people’s health, it is helps people fight viral infections, lowers blood pressure, counts as exercise and lowers the risk of heart attack. It also supposedly improves sleep and reduces stress. However sex with a stranger can be less meaningful and enjoyable than sex with a loving partner leaving people feeling vulnerable, and in that case these assertions may not hold true.
The biggest feminist issue with Prostitution is that it is the literal commodification of women’s bodies. By legalising it as a society we suggest it is acceptable to view a person as a purchase, and that 'buying' a woman for sex is appropriate. However some people may ask what is the difference between selling your body through sex, and selling any other service, for example your strength, or stripping off for a porn magazine. The view is that between two consenting, un-manipulated adults there isn’t an issue with them having sex. People have sex for gifts, for dinner with people they don’t like when they are drunk, sex is just sex. Potentially the abhorrence towards prostitution in the current day is more to do with our veneration of sex, rather than the actual payment.
Many of these arguments come down to the veneration of sex, whether or not you think love is important in sex, or if sex is simply about pleasure. If it is your personal belief that sex isn't just about pleasure and that it must be done with the right person at the right time, then prostitution should obviously be illegal, because it corrupts that idea.
Quick run down on why people don’t like prostitution:
• Its potentially abusive
• It is not viewed as a respectable or suitable career, however this stigma is also linked to our veneration of sex and the disgust society still feels at sexual desire.
• It is the literal commodifictation of women’s bodies.
Reasons prostitution should be completely legalised:
• Allows for regulation – stops links with Human trafficking, drugs and the criminal underworld
• Allows for legislation to protect prostitutes from exploitation
• Could be taxed, this money could then be put back in to supporting prostitutes.
• Means that the identities of abusive clients can be obtained and they can be arrested
• De-stigmatises prostitutes and enables society to help them
In my opinion prostitution should be legal, for although it seems like a horrific profession, with the right help and guidance it can become less brutal and dangerous for prostitutes. Equally, legalising it will provide a legitimate form of income for women. Despite being a hangover from a sexist and oppressive time, if there are going to be prosititues, as women and as humans, we must do all we can to support and protect them. Prostitution will a be a profession that is not closely tied to the black market, the streets and the underworld but instead something much safer. If legalised completely then a woman will be able to reach out for help when needed, and trust in the help of the police and justice system. Prostitution is a commodification of women’s bodies, however it is unlikely to ever go away, and at this point improving actual lives must come before feminist ideals.
Written by Juliette
Picture credit: Willow